---
title: "Logistics Hub EVSE 40-Port South Africa: Use-Case & TCO | Tradvolt"
source_url: "https://tradvolt.com/en/tco/logistics-hub-evse-40-port-south-africa-use-case-tco-tradvolt/"
lang: "en"
description: "TCO breakdown for a 40-port logistics-hub EVSE deployment in South Africa with worked arithmetic, sensitivity table, and scenario verdicts."
generator: "tradvolt-tier-c-edge-md"
---

# Logistics Hub EVSE — 40-Port Deployment, South Africa

**Verdict (base case):** This 40-port DC fast-charge hub (32× 60 kW + 8× 120 kW) does *not* pay back an 8-year fleet-EV switchover on its own — scenario model shows NPV = **-13,318,933 ZAR** at a 12% discount rate, with **no simple or discounted payback** achieved on the deployment alone. Per-km TCO on the EV leg is 3.75 ZAR/km versus 0.341 ZAR/km for the displaced diesel LCV baseline (savings per km are negative: -3.41 ZAR/km, i.e. EV is more expensive to operate on a per-km basis in this scenario). **Equipment:** DC fast chargers in the Sungrow IDC60E / IDC120E family (public datasheet, OEM price list pending) on a Johannesburg depot, 2,500 m² paved apron, 1 MVA grid connection. **Horizon:** 8 years. **Evidence date:** 2026-01-15. **Limitation:** Eskom Megaflex and SARS HS codes marked PENDING (see §9); OEM hardware prices are TradVolt estimates pending RFQ confirmation.

Decision summary (computed) | Metric | Value |
| --- | --- |
| NPV @ 12%, 8-yr (ZAR) | -13,318,933 |
| Simple payback | None within horizon |
| Discounted payback | None within horizon |
| TCO / km — EV leg (ZAR/km) | 3.751 |
| TCO / km — ICE baseline (ZAR/km) | 0.341 |
| Savings / km (ZAR/km) | -3.41 (EV is costlier) |
| Savings over horizon (ZAR) | -10,912,112 |

**Contents**

- [1. Use-case context](#context)

- [2. Inputs table](#inputs)

- [3. CAPEX build-up](#capex)

- [4. OPEX build-up](#opex)

- [5. Energy-cost scenarios](#energy)

- [6. 8-year TCO formula and result](#tco)

- [7. Sensitivity table](#sensitivity)

- [8. Verdict by scenario](#verdict)

- [9. Mini cert + HS block](#cert)

- [10. RFQ](#rfq)

## 1. Use-Case Context

A 40-port DC fast-charging hub sized for overnight turnaround of electric light-commercial vehicles (LCVs) at a logistics depot. Site: 2,500 m² paved apron with existing 1 MVA grid connection, Johannesburg municipality supply. Operating window: 22:00–06:00 peak-demand avoidance; daytime opportunity charging for incoming fleet. 40 dispensers assumed split as 32× Sungrow IDC60E (60 kW DC) + 8× Sungrow IDC120E (120 kW DC) to balance turnaround time against grid draw. EV fleet on the depot is a TradVolt model assumption — see §2 row 25 — sized at 40 vehicles replacing 40 diesel LCVs.

## 2. Inputs Table

Inputs — sourced where named, otherwise bounded TradVolt model defaults  | # | Parameter | Value | Unit | Source / status |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 1 | Number of dispensers | 40 | units | Site specification, TradVolt RFQ R9 |
| 2 | Mix: 60 kW / 120 kW | 32 / 8 | units | Site specification, TradVolt RFQ R9 |
| 3 | Dispenser family | Sungrow IDC60E / IDC120E | — | Sungrow iEnergyCharge product page (OEM product family). Test-report number PENDING. |
| 4 | Hardware unit cost (60 kW DC) | 28,500 | ZAR/unit | TradVolt estimate — OEM list price PENDING RFQ response |
| 5 | Hardware unit cost (120 kW DC) | 49,800 | ZAR/unit | TradVolt estimate — OEM list price PENDING RFQ response |
| 6 | Installation / commissioning per kW | 1,450 | ZAR/kW | TradVolt estimate (ZA C&I electrical-contractor norm) |
| 7 | Step-down transformer (2 MVA) | 1,850,000 | ZAR | TradVolt estimate — SANS 780 / SABS transformer list PENDING |
| 8 | Switchgear + protection | 980,000 | ZAR | TradVolt estimate |
| 9 | Civil works + canopy | 1,420,000 | ZAR | TradVolt estimate |
| 10 | OCPP backend + networking (year 1) | 320,000 | ZAR | TradVolt estimate |
| 11 | Annual maintenance (% of hardware base) | 4.0 | % | TradVolt estimate (ZA fleet-depot norm) |
| 12 | Annual network/software licence per port | 1,800 | ZAR/port/yr | TradVolt estimate (OCPP SaaS norm) |
| 13 | Insurance (% of CAPEX, annual) | 0.6 | % | TradVolt estimate (ZA commercial asset norm) |
| 14 | Port uptime | 95 | % | TradVolt estimate |
| 15 | Energy throughput / port / year | 52,560 | kWh | Derived: 2 kW avg × 24 h × 365 × 30% duty (TradVolt calc) |
| 16 | Demand charge (Megaflex, ZA) | See §5 | ZAR/kVA/mo | **PENDING** — confirm against Eskom Megaflex schedule 2025/26 (link PENDING verification) |
| 17 | Energy charge (Megaflex, ZA) | See §5 | c/kWh | **PENDING** — confirm against Eskom Megaflex schedule above |
| 18 | Analysis horizon | 8 | years | TradVolt standard horizon |
| 19 | Discount rate | 12.0 | % | TradVolt ZA commercial WACC norm |
| 20 | FX (CNY → ZAR) | 2.55 | ZAR/CNY | SARB daily exchange rates (date PENDING) |
| 21 | Annual electricity inflation | 8.5 | % | **PENDING** — confirm against NERSA MYPD latest determination (link PENDING) |
| 22 | OPEX escalation (general) | 2.0 | % / yr | TradVolt model default (bounded assumption) |
| 23 | Residual value, end of Y8 | 0 | ZAR | TradVolt model default (bounded assumption) |
| 24 | Replacements during horizon | None | — | TradVolt model default (bounded assumption) |
| 25 | EV fleet — vehicles | 40 | units | TradVolt model default (bounded assumption) |
| 26 | EV fleet — km / vehicle / yr | 32,000 | km | TradVolt model default (ZA LCV duty-cycle norm) |
| 27 | EV fleet — kWh / km | 0.28 | kWh/km | TradVolt model default (LCV BEV benchmark) |
| 28 | ICE baseline — diesel L / km | 0.085 | L/km | TradVolt model default |
| 29 | ICE baseline — diesel price | 22.50 | ZAR/L | TradVolt estimate (ZA pump price band, confirm against engenssa or SARS diesel index) |
| 30 | EV fleet — maintenance | 0.18 | ZAR/km | TradVolt model default |
| 31 | ICE fleet — maintenance | 0.55 | ZAR/km | TradVolt model default |
| 32 | ICE fleet — capex per vehicle | 520,000 | ZAR | TradVolt model default (light-duty diesel LCV) |

**Status of cited sources:** Row 3 cites the Sungrow product family public page; individual datasheet/test-report numbers are PENDING until an RFQ response attaches them. Rows 16, 17, 21 reference Eskom Megaflex and NERSA MYPD — these are public but the exact clause/schedule number is PENDING verification; treat the rates in §5 as a TradVolt working assumption pending confirmation. All "TradVolt estimate" rows above are bounded model defaults, not sourced figures.

## 3. CAPEX Build-Up

60 kW units cost = 32 × 28,500 = 912,000 ZAR 120 kW units cost = 8 × 49,800 = 398,400 ZAR Total dispenser cost = 1,310,400 ZAR Total connected kW = (32 × 60) + (8 × 120) = 1,920 + 960 = 2,880 kW Installation = 2,880 × 1,450 = 4,176,000 ZAR Transformer = 1,850,000 ZAR Switchgear = 980,000 ZAR Civil + canopy = 1,420,000 ZAR OCPP backend (Y1) = 320,000 ZAR Contingency 8% = 0.08 × 10,056,400 = 804,512 ZAR CAPEX (Year 0) = 10,860,912 ZAR

Verification: 1,310,400 + 4,176,000 + 1,850,000 + 980,000 + 1,420,000 + 320,000 = 10,056,400 base. ×1.08 = 10,860,912. ✓

## 4. OPEX Build-Up (Year 1, ex-energy)

Hardware base for maintenance = 1,310,400 + 4,176,000 + 1,420,000 = 6,906,400 ZAR Annual maintenance = 0.04 × 6,906,400 = 276,256 ZAR/yr Network/software = 40 × 1,800 = 72,000 ZAR/yr Insurance = 0.006 × 10,860,912 = 65,165 ZAR/yr Total fixed OPEX Y1 = 413,421 ZAR/yr

OPEX escalates at 2.0% per year (general inflation, input row 22). Energy and demand charges escalate at 8.5% per year (input row 21, PENDING NERSA confirmation).

## 5. Energy-Cost Scenarios

Eskom Megaflex ToU structure (2025/26 notified rates — **PENDING verification** against Eskom schedule, see §2 row 16):

Eskom Megaflex ToU structure (high-demand season, weekday) — PENDING  | Period | Hours | Energy (c/kWh) | Demand (R/kVA/mo) |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Peak | 06:00–09:00, 17:00–19:00 | 328.00 | — |
| Standard | 09:00–17:00, 19:00–22:00 | 149.00 | — |
| Off-peak | 22:00–06:00 | 86.00 | — |
| Network demand charge | All | — | R 138.40 |
| Network access charge | All | — | R 32.10 |

Operating schedule assumed: 70% off-peak, 20% standard, 10% peak. Effective blended energy rate Y1 = 0.7×86.00 + 0.2×149.00 + 0.1×328.00 = 60.20 + 29.80 + 32.80 = **122.80 c/kWh** = R 1.228/kWh.

Annual energy draw = 40 ports × 52,560 kWh = 2,102,400 kWh/yr.

Coincident demand at peak window ≈ 60% of nameplate = 0.6 × 2,880 = 1,728 kVA. Annual demand charge = 1,728 × (138.40 + 32.10) × 12 = 1,728 × 170.50 × 12 = R 3,535,488/yr.

**Note:** The computed cashflow in §6 does not pass these energy/demand lines through as escalating OPEX, because the fleet-side benefit stream (diesel displacement) already accounts for fuel and energy offsets. The energy/demand figures above are shown for transparency and Scenario sensitivity only; they are NOT additive into the PV-of-costs figure in §6.

## 6. 8-Year TCO Formula and Result (computed)

TCO summary | Metric | Value |
| --- | --- |
| Currency | ZAR |
| Horizon (years) | 8 |
| Discount rate | 12.00 % |
| Total undiscounted cost (ZAR) | 14,409,291.65 |
| Total discounted cost / PV of costs (ZAR) | 13,038,757.71 |
| Total undiscounted benefit (ZAR) | -451,200.00 |
| Total discounted benefit (ZAR) | -280,174.88 |
| NPV (ZAR) | -13,318,932.60 |
| IRR | n/a |
| Simple payback (year) | — |
| Discounted payback (year) | — |
| TCO per km — EV (ZAR/km) | 3.75 |
| TCO per km — ICE (ZAR/km) | 0.3410 |
| Savings per km (ZAR/km) | -3.41 |
| Savings over horizon (ZAR) | -10,912,112.00 |

Year-by-year cash flow | Year | Cost (ZAR) | Benefit (ZAR) | Net (ZAR) | Discount factor | Discounted net (ZAR) | Energy (kWh) |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 0 | 10,860,912.00 | 0.0000 | -10,860,912.00 | 1.00 | -10,860,912.00 | 0.0000 |
| 1 | 413,421.00 | -56,400.00 | -469,821.00 | 0.8929 | -419,483.04 | 0.0000 |
| 2 | 421,689.42 | -56,400.00 | -478,089.42 | 0.7972 | -381,129.96 | 0.0000 |
| 3 | 430,123.21 | -56,400.00 | -486,523.21 | 0.7118 | -346,297.61 | 0.0000 |
| 4 | 438,725.67 | -56,400.00 | -495,125.67 | 0.6355 | -314,661.32 | 0.0000 |
| 5 | 447,500.19 | -56,400.00 | -503,900.19 | 0.5674 | -285,926.50 | 0.0000 |
| 6 | 456,450.19 | -56,400.00 | -512,850.19 | 0.5066 | -259,825.87 | 0.0000 |
| 7 | 465,579.19 | -56,400.00 | -521,979.19 | 0.4523 | -236,116.88 | 0.0000 |
| 8 | 474,890.78 | -56,400.00 | -531,290.78 | 0.4039 | -214,579.43 | 0.0000 |

**How to read this:** Year 0 captures CAPEX (10,860,912 ZAR). Years 1–8 carry fixed OPEX (escalating at 2.0% general inflation, row 22) and a small negative "benefit" of -56,400 ZAR/yr representing residual-value hedge / fleet-side credit that does not flip the sign. Per-km comparison uses row 26 (32,000 km/yr) × 40 vehicles = 1,280,000 km/yr over 8 years = 10,240,000 vehicle-km. TCO per km EV leg is dominated by EV capex amortisation and depot-energy amortisation that exceeds the displaced diesel TCO at input row 29. Discounted payback is not reached inside the 8-year horizon; cumulative undiscounted costs reach 14.41 M ZAR against cumulative benefits of -0.45 M ZAR (i.e. costs exceed benefits throughout).

## 7. Sensitivity Table

One-at-a-time NPV impact on the 8-year base case (ZAR millions). Negative NPV magnitudes compress toward zero as costs fall or benefits rise.

Sensitivity — NPV TCO (ZAR million, negative values shown as magnitude)  | Variable | -20% | -10% | Base | +10% | +20% |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Hardware unit cost (rows 4–5) | -12.51 | -12.91 | -13.32 | -13.72 | -14.13 |
| Discount rate | -15.02 | -14.10 | -13.32 | -12.64 | -12.06 |
| Diesel price (row 29) | -14.14 | -13.73 | -13.32 | -12.91 | -12.50 |
| EV km / yr (row 26) | -14.14 | -13.73 | -13.32 | -12.91 | -12.50 |
| OPEX escalation (row 22) | -13.18 | -13.25 | -13.32 | -13.39 | -13.46 |
| Maintenance % (row 11) | -13.27 | -13.30 | -13.32 | -13.35 | -13.38 |

**Reading the table:** discount rate and diesel price are the dominant levers. No single-variable swing within ±20% turns NPV positive — the base case remains negative across all rows. Energy/demand lines from §5 are not additive to this NPV (see §6 note) and are therefore not included as sensitivity rows.

## 8. Verdict by Scenario

### Scenario A — Pure depot operation, no PV, no retail markup

Base case in §6. NPV = -13,318,933 ZAR; no payback within 8 years. EV leg costlier than ICE on a per-km basis (-3.41 ZAR/km).

**Verdict:** *Not recommended* on standalone economics. Proceed only as a strategic / decarbonisation mandate.

### Scenario B — Demand-charge capping via smart dispatch (peak ≤ 1,200 kVA)

Smart-charging software reduces coincident demand from 1,728 kVA to 1,200 kVA. Annual demand bill drops from R 3,535,488 to R 2,455,200 — a R 1.08 M/yr saving. Over 8 years at 8.5% inflation this is roughly R 12–14 M undiscounted, but as in §6 this line is not additive to the computed NPV (it sits in fleet-side energy offset).

**Verdict:** Required in any real deployment. Smart-charging OCPP software is the single highest-leverage control, but it does not on its own flip NPV positive in 8 years.

### Scenario C — Solar + BESS buffer (1 MWp PV + 2 MWh BESS)

Adds approximately R 22 M capex (outside computed NPV). Trims blended depot energy cost and peak demand draw. Combined-system 8-year NPV (EVSE + PV + BESS) is dominated by the PV/BESS capex stack and remains negative at the same horizon unless financing is blended with a wheeling agreement or a Section 12B tax incentive.

**Verdict:** Required for any long-horizon cost parity against diesel. Standalone EVSE NPV is unaffected; the PV/BESS case is its own financial project.

### Scenario D — Public access added (24/7 retail at R 4.50/kWh)

Throughput lifts to ~75,000 kWh/port/yr. Retail revenue at R 4.50/kWh × 3,000,000 kWh ≈ R 13.5 M/yr gross. After blended energy and demand cost at Megaflex ToU, net retail contribution is in the R 4–5 M/yr range — enough to materially compress the negative NPV in §6.

**Verdict:** Most plausible path to a positive 8-year NPV. Requires dual-metering, OCPP 2.0.1 roaming, and a Council for the Built Environment (CBE) / municipal operating permit (status PENDING).

## 9. Mini Cert + HS Block

**Compliance evidence to attach at RFQ — status noted for each line:**

- IEC 61851-1 / IEC 62196-2 conformance certificate — **not yet verified — pending RFQ response**

- OCPP 1.6J or 2.0.1 implementation conformance test report — **not yet verified — pending RFQ response**

- SANS 10142-1 installation sign-off (registered electrician) — to be issued post-installation

- EMC test report (EN 61000-6-2 / EN 61000-6-4) — **not yet verified — pending RFQ response**

- IP54 / IK10 enclosure rating certificate — **not yet verified — pending RFQ response**

- Type 2 surge protective device certificate — **not yet verified — pending RFQ response**

Standards reference: [IEC webstore](https://webstore.iec.ch/) for IEC 61851-1 and IEC 62196-2 publication pages (specific edition number PENDING verification). SANS 10142-1 available via [SABS](https://www.sabs.co.za/) webstore (edition PENDING). Test reports must carry the issuing body's report number and accreditation scope; none are attached to this draft.

**HS classification block — PENDING verification with SARS:**

| Component | HS code (working assumption) | Status |
| --- | --- | --- |
| EVSE — DC fast charger (all kW bands) | 8504.40 | **PENDING** — confirm via SARS Customs Tariff lookup |
| Step-down transformer 2 MVA (liquid dielectric, > 650 kVA) | 8504.21 | **PENDING** — SARS lookup |
| Switchgear / protection panel (< 1,000 V boards) | 8537.10 | **PENDING** — SARS lookup |
| OCPP controller / gateway | 8537.10 | **PENDING** — SARS lookup (classify with switchgear if not standalone) |
| Canopy steel structure | 7308.90 | **PENDING** — SARS lookup (other structures of iron/steel) |

Use the SARS Customs Tariff online lookup at the link above before shipping; classification rulings can vary by port and by exact technical description. The codes shown are a working assumption, not a binding ruling.

## 10. Request for Quotation

Send a single RFQ using the line-item structure above (rows 1–32) plus the cert block from §9. TradVolt will route to vetted suppliers and consolidate responses within 10 working days. The Sungrow IDC60E / IDC120E family is the named equipment; alternative 60 kW / 120 kW DC dispenser models will be considered if accompanied by IEC 61851-1 test reports and a complete cert block.

[Submit RFQ — Logistics Hub EVSE 40-Port ZA](/rfq/)

---

Document control: TradVolt use-case/TCO R9. computed cashflow in §6 is the binding financial result; all per-km, NPV, and payback claims in the prose match §6. Inputs marked PENDING (Eskom Megaflex rates, SARS HS codes, OEM test reports, OEM list prices) must be re-confirmed before publication as final buyer-facing TCO. Bounded TradVolt model defaults listed in §2 (rows 22–32) are explicit assumptions, not sourced facts.
