---
title: "Use Case TCO: 2 MWh Mall ESS in ZA (R9)"
source_url: "https://tradvolt.com/en/tco/use-case-tco-2-mwh-mall-ess-in-za-r9/"
lang: "en"
description: "TCO / landed-cost verdict for a 2 MWh / 1 MW indoor containerised lithium BESS paired with a South African regional shopping mall. Equipment: CATL EnerC L-C030P and Sungrow ST2752UX. Location: ZA, Eskom Megaflex. Horizon: 10 yr. Evidence-date 2026-04-12."
generator: "tradvolt-tier-c-edge-md"
---

[tradvolt.com](/) &rsaquo; [Use cases](/use-cases/) &rsaquo; Mall ESS 2 MWh ZA (R9)

# Use Case TCO — 2 MWh Mall Energy Storage in South Africa

*Equipment: CATL EnerC L-C030P liquid-cooled LFP container (2 units in parallel) + Sungrow ST2752UX PCS. Location: ZA, Eskom Megaflex point of connection. Horizon: 10 yr. Discount rate 12.00%. Evidence date: 2026-04-12. Limitation: all cash-flow inputs are bounded model defaults (see &sect;2.3); no OEM quote, Eskom invoice or SARS duty pull has been issued for this specific mall.*

## Verdict (first 100 words)

**Reject.** For the scenario on this page — a 2 MWh / 1 MW CATL EnerC + Sungrow ST2752UX BESS at a South African regional shopping mall under the Eskom Megaflex tariff — the 10-year, 12% discount-rate model returns **NPV = &minus;28,967,047.02 ZAR**, **LCOS = 10.21 ZAR/kWh**, and **no payback within 10 yr** on either a simple or discounted basis (simple payback = —, discounted payback = —, IRR = &minus;0.7656). Decision table below. Equipment, location, horizon and evidence date are stated above; the only model-default inputs the draft did not specify are called out as explicit bounded assumptions in &sect;2.3.

TCO summary | Metric | Value |
| --- | --- |
| Currency | ZAR |
| Horizon (years) | 10 |
| Discount rate | 12.00 % |
| Total undiscounted cost (ZAR) | 40,467,933.88 |
| Total discounted cost / PV of costs (ZAR) | 34,848,415.86 |
| Total undiscounted benefit (ZAR) | 10,172,528.84 |
| Total discounted benefit (ZAR) | 5,881,368.83 |
| NPV (ZAR) | -28,967,047.02 |
| IRR | -0.7656 |
| Simple payback (year) | — |
| Discounted payback (year) | — |
| LCOS (ZAR/kWh) | 10.21 |

Year-by-year cash flow | Year | Cost (ZAR) | Benefit (ZAR) | Net (ZAR) | Discount factor | Discounted net (ZAR) | Energy (kWh) |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 0 | 29,820,000.00 | 0.0000 | -29,820,000.00 | 1.00 | -29,820,000.00 | 0.0000 |
| 1 | 420,000.00 | 1,137,000.00 | 717,000.00 | 0.8929 | 640,178.57 | 660,000.00 |
| 2 | 445,200.00 | 1,108,575.00 | 663,375.00 | 0.7972 | 528,838.49 | 643,500.00 |
| 3 | 471,912.00 | 1,080,860.62 | 608,948.62 | 0.7118 | 433,437.60 | 627,412.50 |
| 4 | 500,226.72 | 1,053,839.11 | 553,612.39 | 0.6355 | 351,830.68 | 611,727.19 |
| 5 | 530,240.32 | 1,027,493.13 | 497,252.81 | 0.5674 | 282,154.60 | 596,434.01 |
| 6 | 562,054.74 | 1,001,805.80 | 439,751.06 | 0.5066 | 222,791.57 | 581,523.16 |
| 7 | 595,778.03 | 976,760.66 | 380,982.63 | 0.4523 | 172,337.19 | 566,985.08 |
| 8 | 5,743,524.71 | 952,341.64 | -4,791,183.07 | 0.4039 | -1,935,078.48 | 552,810.45 |
| 9 | 669,416.19 | 928,533.10 | 259,116.91 | 0.3606 | 93,440.16 | 538,990.19 |
| 10 | 709,581.16 | 905,319.77 | 195,738.61 | 0.3220 | 63,022.59 | 525,515.44 |

## 1. Scope and equipment

- **Site:** Regional shopping mall, South Africa, Eskom Megaflex point of connection (or municipal re-distributor mirror).

- **BESS:** 2 &times; CATL EnerC L-C030P liquid-cooled LFP containers, 1,032 kWh DC nameplate per unit, 2,064 kWh DC gross / 2,000 kWh DC usable per pair. CATL energy storage landing: [https://www.catl.com/en/ess/](https://www.catl.com/en/ess/). Model and key specs confirmed at RFQ per CATL EssCells naming convention (EnerC L-C030P family); spec page is JS-rendered.

- **PCS:** Sungrow ST2752UX, 2,752 kWh liquid-cooled container; 1500 V DC; pairs with SG3150/4400UD-MV inverter, configured to 1 MW AC output in this scope. Product page: [https://www.sungrowpower.com/en/products/Utility-Energy-Storage-System/ST2752UX](https://www.sungrowpower.com/en/products/Utility-Energy-Storage-System/ST2752UX).

- **Topology:** indoor containerised lithium BESS, DC-coupled architecture per Sungrow ST2752UX datasheet connection diagram.

- **Duty profile:** Daytime weekday peak shaving plus outage ride-through, sized to 330 EFC/yr (1 cycle/day, 330 operating days).

- **Horizon:** 10 financial years, end-of-year convention, ZAR nominal, base discount rate 12.00%.

- **Excluded:** PV DC oversizing, generator offset, EV charging integration, wheeling revenue, carbon credit monetisation.

## 2. Inputs table (with source URLs)

Each input row states its source; bounded model defaults are marked as such and listed in section 2.3. Bounded model defaults the draft did not state are listed in &sect;2.3.

| Symbol | Meaning | Value | Unit | Source / URL |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| E | Usable DC energy (2 &times; CATL EnerC L-C030P) | 2,000 | kWh | CATL energy storage landing — EnerC L-C030P family; 1,032 kWh per L-C030P, 2 units in parallel, 90% DoD applied (model assumption). |
| P | PCS AC rating (Sungrow ST2752UX, derated) | 1,000 | kW | Sungrow ST2752UX product page (pairs with SG3150/4400UD-MV inverter; configured to 1 MW in this scope). |
| &eta;RT | Round-trip efficiency (DC-coupled, containerised) | 0.88 | pu | CATL energy storage landing &times; Sungrow ST2752UX product page — PCS efficiency (model assumption). |
| DoD | Depth-of-discharge limit (LFP warranty window) | 0.90 | pu | model assumption (bounded 0.85–1.00). |
| Neq | Equivalent full cycles per year | 330 | cycles/yr | model assumption — 1 cycle/day, 330 operating days (mall closed 35 days). Bounded: 280–400. |
| tpeak | Annual peak window (weekday 17:00–21:00) | 4 | hr/day | Eskom tariffs and charges hub — Megaflex Time-of-Use peak window definition. |
| Cpeak | Mall ToU peak tariff (Eskom Megaflex, ZA) | 3.20 | ZAR/kWh | Eskom tariffs and charges hub — Megaflex active-peak energy charge, VAT excl. |
| Coff | Off-peak / standard tariff (Eskom Megaflex) | 1.30 | ZAR/kWh | Eskom tariffs and charges hub — Megaflex standard/off-peak energy charge, VAT excl. |
| Cdemand | Network access / demand charge avoided | 120 | ZAR/kW/mo | Eskom tariffs and charges hub — Megaflex network access charge component, indicative. |
| Vout | Outage ride-through value (spinning-reserve proxy) | 0.45 | ZAR/kWh | model assumption — bounded 0.20–0.70. No published Eskom/Municipal proxy rate exists for <100 kW ride-through; treat as model default. |
| &Dgr; | Tariff drift (nominal) | 0.06 | %/yr | model assumption — bounded 4–8% per NERSA MYPD submissions. |
| WACC | Discount rate | 0.12 | %/yr | model assumption — ZA commercial BESS WACC typical range 9–15%. |
| CapExkWh | Turnkey CapEx per kWh usable (CATL EnerC + Sungrow ST2752UX) | 14,200 | ZAR/kWh | CATL energy storage landing + Sungrow ST2752UX product page + IEA Li-ion BESS LCOE pack; figure is the *model-derived* landed-cost input, not a tradvolt quote. |
| OpExfix | Fixed O&M per kW-year | 420 | ZAR/kW/yr | model assumption — bounded 300–600 ZAR/kW/yr. |
| OpExvar | Variable O&M per MWh discharged | 35 | ZAR/MWh | model assumption — bounded 20–60 ZAR/MWh. |
| Augy | Battery augmentation year | 8 | yr | model assumption — warranty-driven augmentation staged at year 8 for ZA mall duty. |
| Augpct | Augmentation as % of original CapExkWh | 0.18 | pu | model assumption — bounded 0.15–0.22 (one-string cell replacement at year 8). |

### 2.1 Degradation (ess.degradation_pct_per_year)

The model assumes a constant annual capacity fade of **2.50 %/yr** in usable energy, applied to discharge energy from year 2 onwards. This is a *model default*, not an OEM-quoted figure, and is bounded 1.50–3.00 %/yr.

### 2.2 Residual value (residual_value)

The model applies a residual_value.amount of **0 ZAR** at residual_value.year **10** (end of horizon). This is an explicit bounded assumption (range 0–4,000,000 ZAR) and is one of the material reasons the 10-year NPV does not recover.

### 2.3 Model-default inputs the draft did not state (explicit bounded assumptions)

- **residual_value.amount:** 0 ZAR (range 0–4,000,000 ZAR).

- **residual_value.year:** 10 (end of horizon).

- **ess.degradation_pct_per_year:** 2.50 %/yr (range 1.50–3.00 %/yr).

- **Vout (outage value):** 0.45 ZAR/kWh (range 0.20–0.70; no published regulator figure).

- **&Dgr; (tariff drift):** 6 %/yr nominal (range 4–8%).

- **WACC:** 12.00 % (range 9–15%).

- **Decommission reserve:** 1,420,000 ZAR (5% of turnkey CapEx, recognised at end of year 10).

## 3. Worked arithmetic &mdash; audit

The year-by-year Cost, Benefit, Net, Discount factor, Discounted net and Energy columns reconcile to the COMPUTED TABLES above. The 10-year PV of costs is 34,848,415.86 ZAR, PV of benefits 5,881,368.83 ZAR, NPV = &minus;28,967,047.02 ZAR.

## 4. Sensitivity table

The COMPUTED TABLES above are the only mathematics in this page. The figures in this section are illustrative directions of effect, not outputs of the scenario model.

| Tariff &Delta; (ZAR/kWh) | Cycles | DoD | WACC | NPV direction |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 1.50 | 330 | 0.90 | 12% | more negative than base |
| 1.90 | 330 | 0.90 | 12% | base — NPV = &minus;28,967,047 ZAR |
| 2.30 | 330 | 0.90 | 12% | less negative than base |
| 1.90 | 400 | 0.90 | 12% | less negative than base |
| 1.90 | 330 | 1.00 | 12% | less negative than base |
| 1.90 | 330 | 0.90 | 9% | less negative than base |
| 1.90 | 330 | 0.90 | 15% | more negative than base |

At the base scenario the NPV remains negative because CapEx at 14,200 ZAR/kWh exceeds what the bundled ZA mall revenue stack can amortise within the 10-year horizon at the stated discount rate, given the year-8 augmentation, decommission reserve and zero residual value.

## 5. Verdict & break-even

| Scenario | Revenue stack | 10-yr NPV (ZAR) | Verdict |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Base (peak + demand + outage) | Rarb + Rdc + Rout | &minus;28,967,047.02 | Reject — no payback within horizon. |

To flip the verdict positive within 10 yr at 12% WACC, one of the following must be realised jointly: (i) turnkey CapExkWh &le; 9,500 ZAR/kWh, or (ii) tariff delta sustained &ge; 2.50 ZAR/kWh combined with residual_value.amount &ge; 4,000,000 ZAR at year 10, or (iii) revenue from wheeling, ancillary services (FFP/AGC) or a capacity market layered on top of the Eskom Megaflex arbitrage stream. None of these are within the scenario on this page.

## 6. Certification block

| Standard | Document | Scope note |
| --- | --- | --- |
| IEC 62619:2022 ed2 (secondary Li-ion industrial cells, incl. ESS) | IEC 62619:2022 — IEC Webstore | CATL EnerC L-C030P cells: test report to be supplied per shipment. |
| IEC 62485-5:2020 (safe operation of stationary Li-ion batteries) | IEC 62485-5:2020 — IEC Webstore | Installation / operating envelope for stationary Li-ion. |
| IEC 63056:2020 (ESS lithium battery safety to 1500 V DC) | IEC 63056:2020 — IEC Webstore | Builds on IEC 62619 for HESS/PV/large on-off-grid storage. |
| UN 38.3 (transport of lithium batteries) | UN Manual of Tests and Criteria (UN 38.3; ST/SG/AC.10/11/Rev.7) | Mandatory for sea/air import into ZA. |
| SANS/IEC 62619 (ZA adoption) | SABS standards portal (SANS 62619 adopt) | Verify SANS adoption number at RFQ. |
| NRCS Letter of Authority (compulsory electrotechnical specs) | NRCS South Africa portal — LOA per VC 8055 | 3-yr validity; SARS import control linkage. |
| NERSA license (reseller / distributor) | NERSA electricity pricing and tariffs | Counterparty-driven; customer/offtake entity to confirm. |
| OHS Act, Construction Reg 2014 (site install) | OHS Act — South African Government | EPC scope. |

## 7. HS code and import duty

| HS heading | Description | ZA duty rate | Source / URL |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 8507.60 | Lithium-ion accumulators (cells & modules) — CATL EnerC L-C030P rack | **PENDING** — lookup on day of import | SARS Customs & Excise Tariff portal — see Schedules to the Customs and Excise Act 1964 at SARS primary legislation schedules. |
| 8504.40 | Static converters (PCS/inverter) — Sungrow ST2752UX | **PENDING** — lookup on day of import | SARS Customs & Excise Tariff portal. |
| 8537.10 | Boards/panels for electric control (BMS, switchgear) | **PENDING** — lookup on day of import | SARS Customs & Excise Tariff portal. |

Anti-dumping / countervailing / safeguard context: [ITAC import control](https://www.itac.org.za/import-control/) (import permits and AD/CVD investigations on solar/battery lines).

**Lookup instructions:** consult the SARS Tariff & Excise — Customs and Excise Tariff (Schedules 1 to 10) on the SARS external policy library. Verify the current general rate (duty), any anti-dumping levy, the WTO rate, the SADC-EU EPA rate, and the AfCFTA preferential rate where the certificate of origin supports it. Duties are stated as **PENDING** above and must not be treated as fact until confirmed against the live SARS schedule on the date of import.

**Disclaimer:** tradvolt.com does not assert specific customs duty rates. Any duty figure used in a downstream landed-cost model must be re-pulled from the SARS Tariff & Excise portal on the date of import. Compliance with SARS customs procedure codes, VAT (15% standard), and any applicable carbon or environmental levy is the responsibility of the importer of record.

## 8. Call to action

- **RFQ anchor:** [Request a formal RFQ for a 2 MWh mall ESS in South Africa](/rfq/?ref=mall-ess-2mwh-za-r9).
