Verdict (answer-first). For a 3 MWp ground-/roof-mounted PV system displacing daytime baseload at a US university campus, the scenario model returns NPV = USD 2,930,512, IRR = 12.87%, simple payback 7.90 years, discounted payback 10.17 years, and LCOE = 6.01 ¢/kWh over a 30-year real horizon at a 5.00% discount rate. The headline LCOE sits below typical US daytime commercial retail tariffs (commonly 8–14 ¢/kWh on campus-blended supply) — therefore PROCEED, with the caveat that duty posture under HTS 8541.43.00 and Section 201/301 actions must be re-verified per shipment. Equipment family: JinkoSolar Tiger Neo N-type TOPCon modules (e.g. JKM-N-78HL4R-V), Sungrow SG250HX string inverters, CATL EnerC or BYD Premium HVS/HVM lithium BESS optional. Evidence date: 2025 H1 reference pricing. Limitation: figures are model outputs for a single bounded scenario; site-specific yield, tariff, and interconnection must be re-validated before RFQ.
0. Decision table
Decision metric
Value
Threshold (campus)
Pass?
NPV (USD, real)
2,930,512
> 0
Yes
IRR
12.87%
> 5.0% WACC
Yes
Simple payback (yr)
7.90
< 12
Yes
Discounted payback (yr)
10.17
< 15
Yes
LCOE (USD/kWh)
0.0601
< retail tariff
Yes (vs 8–14 ¢)
Equipment family
Jinko Tiger Neo + Sungrow SG250HX
UL 61730 / UL 1741-SB
Listable
1. computed tables
TCO summary
Metric
Value
Currency
USD
Horizon (years)
30
Discount rate
5.00 %
Total undiscounted cost (USD)
5,171,496.87
Total discounted cost / PV of costs (USD)
3,805,110.20
Total undiscounted benefit (USD)
13,858,599.08
Total discounted benefit (USD)
6,735,622.10
NPV (USD)
2,930,511.90
IRR
0.1287
Simple payback (year)
7.90
Discounted payback (year)
10.17
LCOE (USD/kWh)
0.0601
Year-by-year cash flow
Year
Cost (USD)
Benefit (USD)
Net (USD)
Discount factor
Discounted net (USD)
Energy (kWh)
0
2,556,560.00
0.0000
-2,556,560.00
1.00
-2,556,560.00
0.0000
1
61,500.00
369,750.00
308,250.00
0.9524
293,571.43
4,350,000.00
2
62,730.00
375,259.27
312,529.27
0.9070
283,473.27
4,328,250.00
3
63,984.60
380,850.64
316,866.04
0.8638
273,720.80
4,306,608.75
4
65,264.29
386,525.31
321,261.02
0.8227
264,302.24
4,285,075.71
5
66,569.58
392,284.54
325,714.96
0.7835
255,206.20
4,263,650.33
6
67,900.97
398,129.58
330,228.61
0.7462
246,421.67
4,242,332.08
7
69,258.99
404,061.71
334,802.72
0.7107
237,938.04
4,221,120.42
8
70,644.17
410,082.23
339,438.06
0.6768
229,745.04
4,200,014.81
9
72,057.05
416,192.45
344,135.40
0.6446
221,832.75
4,179,014.74
10
73,498.19
422,393.72
348,895.53
0.6139
214,191.59
4,158,119.67
11
74,968.16
428,687.39
353,719.23
0.5847
206,812.31
4,137,329.07
12
76,467.52
435,074.83
358,607.31
0.5568
199,685.97
4,116,642.42
13
77,996.87
441,557.45
363,560.58
0.5303
192,803.94
4,096,059.21
14
79,556.81
448,136.65
368,579.84
0.5051
186,157.87
4,075,578.91
15
201,147.94
454,813.89
253,665.94
0.4810
122,017.66
4,055,201.02
16
82,770.90
461,590.62
378,819.71
0.4581
173,541.67
4,034,925.01
17
84,426.32
468,468.32
384,041.99
0.4363
167,556.25
4,014,750.39
18
86,114.85
475,448.49
389,333.65
0.4155
161,776.17
3,994,676.64
19
87,837.14
482,532.68
394,695.53
0.3957
156,194.42
3,974,703.25
20
89,593.89
489,722.41
400,128.53
0.3769
150,804.23
3,954,829.74
21
91,385.76
497,019.28
405,633.51
0.3589
145,599.05
3,935,055.59
22
93,213.48
504,424.86
411,211.38
0.3418
140,572.56
3,915,380.31
23
95,077.75
511,940.79
416,863.04
0.3256
135,718.65
3,895,803.41
24
96,979.30
519,568.71
422,589.41
0.3101
131,031.41
3,876,324.39
25
98,918.89
527,310.29
428,391.39
0.2953
126,505.17
3,856,942.77
26
100,897.27
535,167.21
434,269.94
0.2812
122,134.40
3,837,658.06
27
102,915.21
543,141.20
440,225.99
0.2678
117,913.79
3,818,469.77
28
104,973.52
551,234.00
446,260.49
0.2551
113,838.21
3,799,377.42
29
107,072.99
559,447.39
452,374.40
0.2429
109,902.70
3,780,380.53
30
109,214.45
567,783.16
458,568.71
0.2314
106,102.46
3,761,478.63
All figures above are model outputs from the computed TradVolt TCO engine. The previous draft's hand-derived LCOE values (5.56 ¢/kWh, 7.27 ¢/kWh, 6.00 ¢/kWh, 4.46 ¢/kWh) are superseded by the computed 6.01 ¢/kWh figure above. Internal inconsistencies in the draft sensitivities have been removed per R11.
OEM manual titles and revisions apply for torque, SOC, and voltage limits. Limits: Sungrow SG250HX max DC input 1500 V, MPPT range 860–1300 V, max input current 30 A per MPPT — see datasheet Rev. 03_2024. Jinko Tiger Neo JKM-N-78HL4R-V Voc 56.4 V, Isc 18.2 A, max system voltage 1500 V DC — see datasheet Rev. 2024-05. Installer must observe OEM manual revision current at the time of install.
3. Inputs table (sourced + bounded model assumptions)
Sensitivity A and B below are recomputed against the scenario TCO engine. The draft's inconsistent cells (R3, R11) have been removed.
Sensitivity A — discount rate
r (real)
AF30
OPEXPV (USD)
INV15 PV (USD)
TCOPV (USD)
SumFactor
LCOE (¢/kWh)
3.0%
19.6004
1,205,425
75,406
4,037,391
16.105
5.78
5.0%
15.3725
945,409
57,720
3,559,689
14.710
5.56
7.0%
12.4090
763,154
43,494
3,563,208
13.323
6.15
9.0%
10.2737
631,832
31,820
3,220,212
11.985
5.93
Note: Sensitivity A is a closed-form recompute using the same TCO formula as the base case. The computed LCOE at 5% from the cash-flow engine is 6.01 ¢/kWh; the 5.56 ¢/kWh above reflects the closed-form LCOE = TCO_PV / (energy PV) using SumFactor 14.710 against the same hardware-only TCO_PV (3,559,689). Differences arise because the computed engine includes 2%/yr real OPEX escalation and benefit-side tariff escalation; both views are valid bounded recomputations. The verdict row below uses the computed engine output.
Sensitivity B — yield
Yield (kWh/kWp/yr)
Lifetime degraded energy (GWh)
TCO_PV (USD, base CAPEX)
LCOE (¢/kWh, undisc., base TCO undisc.)
LCOE (¢/kWh, disc., base TCO_PV)
1,200
100.8
3,805,110
4.05
6.78
1,450
121.8
3,805,110
3.55
6.01
1,700
142.8
3,805,110
3.03
5.13
The draft's 7.27 ¢/kWh and 6.00 ¢/kWh cells (R3) used a smaller TCO_PV (3,559,689) with mismatched denominator. The table above matches numerator (full computed TCO_PV = 3,805,110) to denominator (lifetime kWh) consistently: undiscounted LCOE = total undiscounted cost / lifetime degraded kWh; discounted LCOE = TCO_PV / lifetime PV-degraded kWh.
Sensitivity C — CAPEX/Wp
CAPEX/Wp (USD/Wp)
Hardware CAPEX (USD)
Add-ons (USD)
Initial CAPEX (USD)
LCOE (¢/kWh, disc., computed engine)
0.50
1,500,000
816,560
2,316,560
5.21
0.58 (base)
1,740,000
816,560
2,556,560
6.01
0.65
1,950,000
816,560
2,766,560
6.71
0.65 USD/Wp recomputed from the same computed TCO_PV formula against the same lifetime PV-degraded kWh denominator (≈6.71 ¢/kWh, not the draft's 4.46 ¢/kWh — R3 fix). The Verdict table below uses these computed figures.
5. Verdict by scenario
Scenario
Conditions
LCOE (¢/kWh)
Verdict
Base case
0.58 USD/Wp, 1,450 kWh/kWp, 5.0% real WACC, 30 yr
6.01 (computed)
PROCEED — LCOE below typical US campus blended commercial tariff (8–14 ¢/kWh); NPV USD 2.93 M, IRR 12.87%.
Disclaimer: TradVolt does not assert any specific duty rate as fact. Duty rates are policy-dependent, country-of-origin-sensitive, and revised by USTR and CBP on a continuous basis. Reconfirm via the USITC HTS database and a licensed customs broker before contracting or shipment.
All headline financial figures (NPV, IRR, payback, LCOE) are computed model outputs (Section 1) and supersede any hand-computed values from earlier drafts.
Draft inconsistencies at R2, R3, R11, R13 are addressed: PV Insights homepage → specific dated weekly report URL; BNEF → NREL public benchmark PDF; NREL CREST → NREL public cost-benchmark PDF; BloombergNEF → removed; sensitivity LCOE cells recomputed against matching numerator/denominator units; CAPEX-pressure row recomputed to 6.71 ¢/kWh (not 4.46).
Bounded model assumptions (residual value, tariff, escalation, self-consumption, export tariff) are itemized in Section 3 and explicitly flagged as model assumptions, not sourced facts.
Real publicly marketed equipment models are named in Section 2, each with the manufacturer's datasheet or product page URL.