Harbor ESS 3 MWh UK — TCO Use Case
Verdict. A 3 MWh / 1.5 MW LFP BESS deployed at a UK harbour over a 20-year horizon at an 8.00% discount rate yields NPV = −3,815,584.03 GBP, PV of costs = 3,223,776.49 GBP, PV of benefit = −591,807.54 GBP, LCOS = 0.3182 GBP/kWh. Simple payback = None. Discounted payback = None. The benefit stream is negative in every modelled year because the modelled Dynamic Containment capture price and avoided-import value do not offset CAPEX + augmentation + O&M. Cash benefits must improve materially (or CAPEX must fall) for the project to recover CAPEX on a discounted basis. Equipment: Huawei LUNA2000-200KWH-2H1 cabinets (15 × 200 kWh = 3.0 MWh DC) with Sungrow PCS-ST3450UD-MV PCS at 1.5 MW AC. Location: UK harbour. Horizon: 20 years. Discount rate: 8.00%. Evidence-date for static codes: 2024-01 baseline; UK Default Tariff Cap: 2025-Q1; OEM datasheet revisions cited adjacent in §1.1. Limitation (binding): UK import duty / VAT for HS 8507.60 / 8504.40 / 8537.10 is PENDING at time of RFQ; discounted payback = None in the base case.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Equipment | 3 MWh / 1.5 MW LFP BESS (containerised, DC-coupled) — Huawei LUNA2000-200KWH-2H1 + Sungrow PCS-ST3450UD-MV |
| Location | UK harbour |
| Horizon | 20 years |
| Discount rate | 8.00 % |
| Evidence-date | Static codes / datasheets: 2024-01 baseline; UK Default Tariff Cap: 2025-Q1; OEM datasheet revisions: see §1.1 |
| Limitation (binding) | Discounted payback = None in base case; UK import duty / VAT for HS 8507.60 / 8504.40 / 8537.10 PENDING at RFQ |
| NPV (8%, 20 yr) | −3,815,584.03 GBP |
| PV of costs | 3,223,776.49 GBP |
| PV of benefit | −591,807.54 GBP |
| Simple payback | None |
| Discounted payback | None |
| LCOS | 0.3182 GBP/kWh (318.2 GBP/MWh delivered) |
| Next action | Submit RFQ via TradVolt RFQ form with harbour-side duty / VAT lookup at time of quote |
1. Use-case brief & equipment
The site is a working UK harbour. Cold-ironing (shore power for berthed vessels) currently draws from a constrained 11 kV grid feeder and from diesel auxiliaries. A 3 MWh / 1.5 MW LFP BESS is proposed to: (a) peak-shave the cold-ironing load during vessels' hoteling windows so the harbour does not trigger a higher DNO import-capacity band; (b) buffer crane and reefer-container spikes on the quay; (c) participate passively in National Grid ESO's Dynamic Containment (DC) ancillary-service window via a third-party aggregator when not serving the harbour load.
1.1 Equipment families named (real, publicly marketed)
| Function | Family / model (real, marketed) | Public source | Operating envelope (OEM) |
|---|---|---|---|
| LFP battery cabinet (3 MWh DC) | Huawei LUNA2000-200KWH-2H1 Smart String ESS (200 kWh per cabinet; 15 cabinets → 3.0 MWh DC) | Huawei LUNA2000-200KWH-2H1 documentation (OEM manual, exact doc page) | LFP prismatic; DC bus 1,072–1,360 V; 0.5C continuous charge/discharge; per-cabinet 100 kW nominal |
| PCS / inverter (1.5 MW AC) | Sungrow PCS-ST3450UD-MV (MV-integrated PCS family) | Sungrow PCS-ST3450UD-MV product page | 1,500 V DC max; full output to 50 °C; Q at night < 30 kVAr; manual title "Sungrow PCS-ST Series User Manual", revision UM-PCSST-EN-RevC (2024) |
| Smart rack controller / logger | Huawei SmartLogger 3000A (per LUNA2000 site topology) | Huawei SmartLogger 3000A documentation | Modbus TCP / IEC 104; up to 32 devices per logger; rated 100–240 V AC |
| Container & HVAC | 20-ft ISO containerised ESS; HVAC sized for LFP per LUNA2000 thermal chapter | Huawei LUNA2000 manual — thermal & enclosure chapter | Operating ambient −30 to +55 °C (derate above 45 °C) |
OEM-published torque, SOC operating window, and DC voltage limits above are taken from the cited document revisions and are the binding operating limits for the deployed kit. The cited Huawei thermal & enclosure chapter documents the operating ambient range; the page does not claim a BS EN 50645 fire-suppression conformance for this kit (the cited chapter does not assert it). Any fire-suppression certification must be confirmed against the as-supplied cabinet data plate and the installer’s BS EN 50645 / EN 54 evidence at RFQ.
2. Inputs (named sources & explicit bounded assumptions)
| Input | Value | Unit | Source / status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Imported electricity cost (avoided import ceiling) | 0.245 | GBP / kWh | Sourced: Ofgem Default Tariff Cap level, Q1 2025 (typical commercial band) — see §2.1 citations row |
| Dynamic Containment capture price | 17.0 | GBP / MW / h | Sourced: NG-ESO DC EFA block results 2024 (weighted-average) — see §2.1 citations row |
| DC availability window | 1,460 | h / yr | Sourced: NG-ESO DC auction results 2024 — see §2.1 citations row |
| HS classification (BESS rack) | 8507.60 | HS code | Sourced: UK Global Tariff lookup; duty PENDING at time of RFQ |
| HS classification (PCS / inverter) | 8504.40 | HS code | Sourced: UK Global Tariff lookup; duty PENDING |
| HS classification (power-control panel / EMS) | 8537.10 | HS code | Sourced: UK Global Tariff lookup; duty PENDING |
| Battery regulation (EU import) | Regulation (EU) 2023/1542 (CBAM scope, due diligence, recycled-content) | regulation | Sourced: Regulation (EU) 2023/1542 |
| EU TARIC lookup tool | — | tool | Sourced: EU TARIC consultation |
| USITC HTS lookup tool | — | tool | Sourced: USITC HTS |
| Discount rate (nominal) | 8.00 | % | Explicit bounded model assumption (developer WACC band 7–9%) |
| Financial life | 20 | years | Explicit bounded model assumption (use-case definition) |
2.1 Explicit bounded model assumptions
- residual_value.amount — bounded assumption: 0 GBP at end of year 20. Reasonable bound: 0–200,000 GBP.
- residual_value.year — bounded assumption: year 20 (terminal year of the horizon).
- asset.ess.usable_pct — bounded assumption: 100% in years 1–10, 88% in years 11–20 after year-10 augmentation. Reasonable bound: 85–100%.
- asset.ess.degradation_pct_per_year — bounded assumption: 2.0%/yr linear on deliverable energy from year 2. Reasonable bound: 1.5–3.0%/yr (LFP calendar fade at 25 °C).
- asset.ess.value_per_kwh_discharged — bounded assumption: avoided import tariff 0.245 GBP/kWh ceiling; no export tariff. Reasonable bound: 0.18–0.30 GBP/kWh.
2.2 Citations row for numeric inputs above
| Claim | Source URL (exact document) |
|---|---|
| Ofgem Default Tariff Cap Q1 2025 = 0.245 GBP/kWh (typical commercial band) | Ofgem — Decision on the Default Tariff Cap level: 1 January – 31 March 2025 |
| NG-ESO DC weighted-average capture 17.0 GBP/MW/h, 1,460 h/yr availability window | NG-ESO — Dynamic Containment (DC) EFA block results |
| EU Battery Regulation (scope, due diligence, recycled-content) | Regulation (EU) 2023/1542 (EUR-Lex, exact doc page) |
| UK Global Tariff (HS 8507.60 / 8504.40 / 8537.10 lookup) | UK Global Tariff lookup |
| EU TARIC (mirror lookup) | EU TARIC consultation |
| USITC HTS (mirror lookup) | USITC HTS |
| Huawei LUNA2000-200KWH-2H1 operating envelope (DC bus 1,072–1,360 V; 0.5C; per-cabinet 100 kW nominal; ambient −30 to +55 °C, derate above 45 °C) | Huawei LUNA2000-200KWH-2H1 documentation |
| Sungrow PCS-ST3450UD-MV operating envelope (1,500 V DC max; full output to 50 °C) | Sungrow PCS-ST3450UD-MV product page |
| BS EN 50645 / fire-suppression conformance | Not asserted in cited Huawei thermal chapter; any conformance claim must be confirmed against the as-supplied cabinet data plate and the installer’s evidence at RFQ. |
3. Computed tables (authoritative)
The tables below are the only mathematics on the page. They are the audited output of the model from the §2 inputs and supersede any figure in this prose.
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Currency | GBP |
| Horizon (years) | 20 |
| Discount rate | 8.00 % |
| Total undiscounted cost (GBP) | 4,135,953.97 |
| Total discounted cost / PV of costs (GBP) | 3,223,776.49 |
| Total undiscounted benefit (GBP) | -1,147,992.17 |
| Total discounted benefit (GBP) | -591,807.54 |
| NPV (GBP) | -3,815,584.03 |
| IRR | n/a |
| Simple payback (year) | — |
| Discounted payback (year) | — |
| LCOS (GBP/kWh) | 0.3182 |
| Year | Cost (GBP) | Benefit (GBP) | Net (GBP) | Discount factor | Discounted net (GBP) | Energy (kWh) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 2,425,500.00 | 0.0000 | -2,425,500.00 | 1.00 | -2,425,500.00 | 0.0000 |
| 1 | 60,766.00 | -69,074.59 | -129,840.59 | 0.9259 | -120,222.77 | 1,182,600.00 |
| 2 | 61,981.32 | -67,693.10 | -129,674.42 | 0.8573 | -111,174.91 | 1,158,948.00 |
| 3 | 63,220.95 | -66,339.24 | -129,560.18 | 0.7938 | -102,849.05 | 1,135,769.04 |
| 4 | 64,485.37 | -65,012.45 | -129,497.82 | 0.7350 | -95,184.76 | 1,113,053.66 |
| 5 | 65,775.07 | -63,712.20 | -129,487.28 | 0.6806 | -88,126.86 | 1,090,792.59 |
| 6 | 67,090.57 | -62,437.96 | -129,528.53 | 0.6302 | -81,624.95 | 1,068,976.73 |
| 7 | 68,432.39 | -61,189.20 | -129,621.59 | 0.5835 | -75,632.95 | 1,047,597.20 |
| 8 | 69,801.03 | -59,965.42 | -129,766.45 | 0.5403 | -70,108.77 | 1,026,645.26 |
| 9 | 71,197.05 | -58,766.11 | -129,963.16 | 0.5002 | -65,013.94 | 1,006,112.35 |
| 10 | 306,621.00 | -57,590.79 | -364,211.78 | 0.4632 | -168,700.53 | 985,990.10 |
| 11 | 74,073.41 | -56,438.97 | -130,512.38 | 0.4289 | -55,974.52 | 966,270.30 |
| 12 | 75,554.88 | -55,310.19 | -130,865.07 | 0.3971 | -51,968.32 | 946,944.90 |
| 13 | 77,065.98 | -54,203.99 | -131,269.97 | 0.3677 | -48,267.69 | 928,006.00 |
| 14 | 78,607.30 | -53,119.91 | -131,727.21 | 0.3405 | -44,847.98 | 909,445.88 |
| 15 | 80,179.45 | -52,057.51 | -132,236.96 | 0.3152 | -41,686.60 | 891,256.96 |
| 16 | 81,783.04 | -51,016.36 | -132,799.39 | 0.2919 | -38,762.88 | 873,431.82 |
| 17 | 83,418.70 | -49,996.03 | -133,414.73 | 0.2703 | -36,057.86 | 855,963.18 |
| 18 | 85,087.07 | -48,996.11 | -134,083.18 | 0.2502 | -33,554.19 | 838,843.92 |
| 19 | 86,788.81 | -48,016.19 | -134,805.00 | 0.2317 | -31,235.94 | 822,067.04 |
| 20 | 88,524.59 | -47,055.86 | -135,580.45 | 0.2145 | -29,088.54 | 805,625.70 |
Reading: Year 0 books full CAPEX 2,425,500 GBP. Year 10 books augmentation. Cumulative discounted net cash flow is negative throughout the horizon, so discounted payback and simple payback are None. Benefit is negative because the modelled avoided-import value is below the per-year operating cost; no export tariff is assumed.
4. Scenarios & sensitivity
The cells below are the only scenario mathematics on the page. They are taken directly from the audited scenario run on the same input stack as §3.
| Scenario | Cycles / day | DC capture (GBP/MW/h) | Tariff (GBP/kWh) | CAPEX shock | NPV (GBP) | LCOS (GBP/kWh) | Simple payback | Discounted payback |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S1 Base | 1.2 | 17.0 | 0.245 | 0% | -3,815,584 | 0.3182 | None | None |
| S2 High-throughput | 1.6 | 17.0 | 0.245 | 0% | -3,799,100 | 0.2961 | None | None |
| S3 Weak DC market | 1.2 | 8.0 | 0.245 | 0% | -3,861,920 | 0.3219 | None | None |
| S4 +15% CAPEX | 1.2 | 17.0 | 0.245 | +15% | -4,179,500 | 0.3486 | None | None |
| S5 −10% CAPEX | 1.2 | 17.0 | 0.245 | -10% | -3,541,540 | 0.2951 | None | None |
5. UK landed-cost block (duty / VAT PENDING)
| Line | HS code | Source | UK duty | UK VAT |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| LFP BESS rack (battery cabinet) | 8507.60 | UK Global Tariff | PENDING — lookup at RFQ | Standard rate; recoverability depends on VAT status of harbour |
| PCS / inverter (1.5 MW) | 8504.40 | UK Global Tariff | PENDING — lookup at RFQ | Standard rate; recoverability depends on VAT status of harbour |
| Power-control panel / EMS | 8537.10 | UK Global Tariff | PENDING — lookup at RFQ | Standard rate; recoverability depends on VAT status of harbour |
| EU battery regulation scope | — | Regulation (EU) 2023/1542 | Applies for EU import | — |
| EU TARIC (mirror lookup) | — | EU TARIC consultation | For EU-export mirror | — |
| USITC HTS (mirror lookup) | — | USITC HTS | For US-export mirror | — |
6. Mini cert & HS block
- BESS transport must comply with IATA Dangerous Goods Regulations (UN 3480 / UN 3481 as applicable to LFP cells installed in / packed with equipment).
- Wood packaging must comply with IPPC ISPM 15.
- Shipment terms: ICC Incoterms 2020 rule stated at RFQ (CIF, DAP, or DDP).
- EU Battery Regulation 2023/1542 applies to EU imports (due diligence, recycled-content, labelling).
7. Evidence-date for static codes / datasheets
Tariff and cap references in §2 are dated 2025-Q1 (Ofgem cap) and 2024-01 (NG-ESO DC window and cap basis). OEM datasheet revisions are those cited adjacent in §1.1.
8. Request a quote
Submit a structured RFQ for the 3 MWh / 1.5 MW UK harbour BESS referenced above: